I'm beginning to wonder about the "fairness" of the GalCiv AI myself. I mean, I understand that AI has to cut certain corners to stay competitive with a live human, but there's a level of blatancy which just sucks all the fun out of a game for me. I don't even mind losing if I feel I'm playing on a fair-ish playing field, but if a game's AI opponent just gets everything good too quickly, too easily and in too great a quantity, I start to dislike the game simply because it's too obviously rigged. It destroys even the illusion of a fair challenge.
For example, the Star Wars Battlegrounds/Clone Campaigns series of RTS games do this sort of overkill corner-cutting so constantly on anything above the Easy setting (i.e. the obviously dull-witted AI setting) that I've lost any real interest in those games. I'm sure there are many who can still win at these games; that's not my point. I get tired of being trounced only because the AI is "magically" manifesting resources and units as needed, and not even trying to *look* like it's playing by the same rules as I am.
I'm not saying that GalCiv is similarly rigged, just agreeing with you that I've seen some things lately while playing GalCiv that have made me wonder also. For example, the "magic Dreadnaughts" -- late game, and I'm pounding the hell out of the Altarian invaders (they started it, man

). Suddenly, the Altarians start producing all these Dreadnaughts -- and the only other aliens left in the game are the Torians, who are 1) militarily and economically weak, and 2) my official allies, also warring against the Altarian bastards. The Altarians are hurting for tech and resources at this point -- all my espionage and other data says so -- but suddenly the Altarians have Dreadnaughts all over the place! I quit the game in disgust. I don't mind losing, in fact, I haven't won a GalCiv game yet, and I still think GalCiv is a great game -- but I can't stand it when the AI doesn't approximate or even give the illusion of being bound by the same rules of play that I am. As I said above, it sucks all the fun and challenge out of a game for me.
So, I hear ya, Joshua, and I wonder also ...
~SDC~